Sell Cartier Watches in NYC

Cash for Your Cartier, Not Store Credit. Funded the Same Day.

Sell Cartier watches in NYC for a top cash offer on the spot, whether it's a Santos you wear daily or a Ballon Bleu that's been sitting in a drawer.

4.9
star
star
star
star
star
481 Google reviews
Cartier Santos with a green dial beside a Ballon Bleu with a blue dial
send_money
Get a loan
Borrow against it. Get it back at repayment.
  • check

    No credit check

  • check

    Written in 30-day increments

  • check

    Insured through Jewelers Mutual

Want cash for your Cartier, not a trade-in credit?

Cash Offers

We pay cash for your Cartier, where a brand trade-in only credits a new purchase.

Same-Day Funding

Accept the offer and you're funded immediately, same day, by cash, wire or business check.

Every Model

Santos, Tank, Ballon Bleu, Panthère or an older Roadster, with or without box and papers.

“They immediately took interest in the watch, inspected the condition carefully and made me a fair offer based on market prices.”

Christopher S.
Google review, August 2026

“Although I ultimately decided to keep the bracelet, I appreciated his time and expertise and had an excellent experience.”

Daphne
Google review, October 2026

“What a refreshing experience to deal with people that have compassion for someone parting with sentimental jewelry.”

Marilena M.
Google review, August 2026

Sell Cartier watches in New York, NY for Fast cash

Reading a Cartier, from caseback to caliber

Our watch buyers start with the case number, a four-digit code on the caseback that identifies your exact model. The serial number next to it belongs to your watch alone. Then we confirm the caliber.

We buy the Santos, Tank, Ballon Bleu, Panthère, Pasha and Roadster, quartz or automatic, current or long discontinued. Quartz models usually resell for less. Bring any spare QuickSwitch straps or removed links too.

Cartier Tank Française, Ballon Bleu and Calibre de Cartier watches
Cartier Ballon Bleu in steel with a diamond bezel

Ready to sell a Cartier you've outgrown?

Plenty of New York owners bought a Ballon Bleu or a Roadster five or ten years ago, when they were everywhere. Tastes have moved on since. Others got a Tank as a gift that never quite fit their style.

Some owners assume a Cartier boutique will buy their watch back for cash, then learn the brand's trade-in only credits a new Cartier. Want cash instead? We'll make you an offer.

Why trust us with your Cartier in New York

Manhattan Buyers is licensed by the NYC Department of Consumer and Worker Protection as a secondhand dealer, so the city sets the rules we follow. Every Cartier is checked in house, in front of you. Nothing gets sent out.

Our jewelry buyer team checks Cartier jewelry the same way, so a Love bracelet can come along too. See what nearly 500 Google reviewers say.

Santos de Cartier in steel with a blue dial and bezel
Cartier Tank Louis Cartier in rose gold in its box

When selling your Cartier makes the most sense

If you registered your Cartier with Cartier Care, the warranty can run up to eight years in total. The next owner can register for whatever time is left. That coverage adds value.

Most Cartier sales here take one visit, with a free evaluation and a cash offer based on today's market. Accept, and you're funded immediately, same day. No appointment is needed.

A Cartier watch buyer in Midtown Manhattan

You'll find Manhattan Buyers on Fifth Avenue in Midtown, New York, NY, within easy reach of Chelsea, Tribeca, SoHo and the Upper West Side. Williamsburg is close too. Walk in whenever we're open.

Work near Grand Central Terminal, or take lunch in Bryant Park? You're already in our area. City rules for secondhand dealers apply here, so you'll show an ID, and we'll log the watch's serial number.

Vintage Cartier Santos Galbée in steel and yellow gold
Recent buys

A few of the pieces we've bought recently

Rolex Yacht-Master 42 with a black dial

Rolex Yacht-Master 42

Funded immediately, same day.

Bulgari B.zero1 ring with pavé diamonds

Bulgari B.zero1 diamond ring

Funded immediately, same day.

Vintage Vacheron Constantin square dress watch in yellow gold

Vintage Vacheron Constantin dress watch, yellow gold

Funded immediately, same day.

Diamond cluster stud earrings

Diamond cluster earrings

Funded immediately, same day.

100%

secure & confidential

20+ years

in the business

Same day

funding once you accept an offer

Top 10%

cash offer made to you

Don't sell before you know what it's worth.

Selling several pieces? Call (212) 913-9141 and speak with our team first.

How It Works

1

Request Your Quote

Share your piece's details online and get a free price range.

2

Bring It In

Walk in or book a time. We authenticate and price it in front of you.

3

Get Paid Today

If you accept, you're funded immediately, same day.

Hands inspect a watch, ring, and necklace in a black tray using a magnifying loupe.

Manhattan Buyers vs. Auctions and Online Marketplaces

Manhattan Buyers

Others

Auctions, online marketplaces

Same-day funding
Yes, once you accept
Varies
In-person pricing
Yes, in front of you
Depends on the platform
In-house authentication
Yes
Depends on the provider
Free evaluation
Yes
Varies
Watches, diamonds, gold
All three, one visit
Varies

See what your Items Are worth.

FAQs

How much can you sell a Cartier watch for?

add

Most pre-owned Cartier watches sell below their retail price. Morgan Stanley's 2026 report put the brand's average about 27 percent under retail, a little better than the year before. Your number depends on the model, the metal, the condition and whether it's quartz or automatic. Box and papers help too.

Do Cartier watches resell well?

add

Some models resell much better than others. The Santos holds its value most strongly, keeping roughly 70 to 80 percent of retail by one 2026 estimate, with the Tank Must close behind. The Ballon Bleu and Panthère tend to trade at deeper discounts. Quartz versions usually keep less value than automatics.

Can I sell my Cartier back to Cartier?

add

Not for cash. Cartier's part-exchange service, run with Watchfinder & Co., only gives credit toward a new Cartier creation. The participating boutiques on its US site are in Germany, Switzerland and Hong Kong. If you want money for the watch rather than a new one, sell it to an independent buyer.

Does Cartier Ballon Bleu hold value?

add

It holds value less well than most Cartier models. The Ballon Bleu was everywhere in the years after its 2007 launch, and demand has cooled since. Pre-owned prices usually sit further below retail than a Santos or Tank. Size, metal and condition still make a big difference to the offer.

How do I find out how much my Cartier watch is worth?

add

Find the case number first, the four-digit code on the caseback that identifies your model. Then check recent sale prices for that model in similar condition, not asking prices. An in-person evaluation confirms the movement and condition, which photos alone can't show.

What is the best way to sell a Cartier watch?

add

Gather the box, papers and any spare straps first, since a complete set sells for more. Then get offers from buyers who check the case number and movement in person. We're confident our cash offer lands in the top 5% to 10% of the offers you'll get, funded the same day.

Where is the best place to sell my Cartier watch?

add

Pick a buyer who checks the watch in person and pays the same day. We buy Cartier watches at our Fifth Avenue office in Midtown Manhattan, with a cash offer on the spot. We also buy Cartier jewelry and other luxury watches, so bring them along.

Don't settle for store credit on your Cartier.

Manhattan Buyers is independent and isn't sponsored by or affiliated with Cartier.

Areas Served

Proudly serving New York and its neighborhoods, including the Diamond District, Murray Hill, Chelsea, the Upper East Side, the Upper West Side, SoHo, Tribeca, the Financial District, and beyond.

Sell Your Cartier Watch on Fifth Avenue in New York, NY

Walk in during business hours, or book a time if you'd like us ready for you.

schedule

Hours

Monday to Friday, 10 AM to 6 PM. Saturday, 10 AM to 5 PM. Closed Sunday.

directions_subway

By subway

Taking the subway? Get off at 47-50 Sts-Rockefeller Center on Sixth Avenue. The D and F stop there all day, and the B and M run on weekdays. Use the 47th or 48th Street exit, then walk one block east to Fifth Avenue.

door_front

Building entrance

The building entrance is on Fifth Avenue. Sign in with the doorman in the lobby, then head up to the 10th floor.

local_parking

Parking

Driving in? Two garages sit between Fifth and Sixth Avenues: Icon Parking at 53 W. 48th St. and City Parking at 55 W. 46th St. Both are open 24 hours, fit vehicles up to 6 feet 8 inches tall, and take reservations online.